First of all, if you need background on the controversy, here is a link to an opinion piece published in The New York Times this summer. Click here for the publisher's write-up of the book (keep in mind they are trying to sell the book). Perhaps most interestingly, here is an article about a bookstore that offered refunds to customers who felt duped after purchasing and reading the book. Talk about scandal!
I really wanted to enjoy, like, perhaps just appreciate this book. Harper Lee herself is such an enigma, having never published another book again after To Kill A Mockingbird. I'm trying to view it as a first draft written by a young, idealistic author many years ago, but I'm having a hard time getting past some of her most basic errors, such as switching point-of-view between first- and third- person multiple times in the story. Lee will be referring to Jean Louise by name (the main character) and then all of a sudden, she's in first person, using "I" and "me". It also took a long, long time to get into the main conflict of the story. I believe I was over a third of the way through the novel before conflict actually started happening.
One part I did find interesting related closely to our Honors English narratives, and the requirement to demonstrate inter-textuality by including a poem or research. Lee did just that:
"An absurd verse vibrated in Jean Louise's memory. Where had she read it?
By right Divine, my dear Augusta,
We've had another awful buster;
Ten thousand Frenchmen sent below.
Praise God from Whom all blessings
flow.
She wondered where Hester had pick up her information" (Lee 62 %).
I'm going to work on finishing it, and I'll post my final thoughts at a later date. Have any of you read it? If so, what are your thoughts? Or do you plan on reading it? I'd love to know!
Hi Mrs. Bross! To Kill a Mockingbird is my all-time favorite book! I love the way Harper Lee used Scout's big heart and the way of society to make a change out of the novel. Atticus and Scout were my favorite characters in the book because of the way they stood up to what society said was "right". My dad bought me Go Set a Watchman a few weeks ago but I haven't gotten the chance to read it yet. Would you recommend this book for me? Do Atticus and Scout have big roles?
ReplyDeleteMaddie, I've always love To Kill A Mockingbird, too. Honestly, I don't know if I would recommend it or not. I'll let you know when I finish it. I think as long as you read it for what it is, which is a young author's first draft of a story, it's worth a try. Hope that helps!
DeleteHi Mrs. Bross!! I liked to Kill A Mockingbird and appreciated the book for its interesting theme and enjoyed reading it. After hearing the controversy about go Set A Watchman, I still don't understand why it is such an interestingly controversial book by such a famous author? Does this book drag on and on? Can you please elaborate on that a little more so I can understand??
ReplyDeleteThank you sooo much Mrs. Bross!!